Top Lyrics of 2017
1.
“Share some conjugated meaning / Watch the light drip down your face.”
— VÉRITÉ, “WHEN YOU’RE GONE”
The English major in me delighted when I first heard Vérité drop the word “conjugated” in general, especially in the context of such a quickly-spoken verse, but I was even more delighted when I read her annotations of “When You’re Gone” for Genius and discovered the word had different scientific meanings. In a biological context, the term refers to when bacteria combine to exchange genetic material, which makes whatever sexual encounter she depicts sound even more unpleasant/unfeeling, despite the beauty in the following line of intensely watching light drip down your lover’s face.
________________________________________________________________________
2.
“I’m sorry, the old Taylor can’t come to the phone right now. Why? Oh, ‘cuz she’s DEAD!”
— TAYLOR SWIFT, “LOOK WHAT YOU MADE ME DO”
When Taylor Swift’s comeback single first dropped, I wasn’t entirely on board. It felt forced, like it was trying too hard to be trendy and to single-handedly control the narrative of whatever the next chapter in her career would be. So, when she fakes a phone conversation during the bridge and utters the lines about her old self being dead, I rolled my eyes and laughed out loud simultaneously. Swift is many things, and while meta may be one, it’s so ridiculously laughable it’s actually decent.
________________________________________________________________________
3.
“I bought a bottle of Moscato / You’ll be drunk until tomorrow.”
— BETTY WHO, “YOU CAN CRY TOMORROW”
Betty Who has a knack for choosing a type of wine, inserting it into a romance narrative, and creating an iconic lyric out of it. As a result, her simple purchase of Moscato to help a heartbroken friend get through a breakup on “You Can Cry Tomorrow” is the perfect successor to her exaltation of day-drinking Chardonnay simply because she could on “High Society.”
________________________________________________________________________
4.
“I’m sorry I’m not what you wanted / A blissful expectation of something you never got.”
— VÉRITÉ, “NEED NOTHING”
Calling out a lover for having unrealistic expectations is never an easy conversation to have, and it’s even more difficult to try to genuinely apologize for not meeting those expectations. On “Need Nothing,” Vérité is profoundly aware of just how difficult it can be to acknowledge the sorry state of a relationship and the role her penchant for self-deprecation and self-destruction play in getting the relationship to that state. Her apology rings disingenuous, yet there is something extremely powerful in her juxtaposition of it with the phrase, “a blissful expectation.” It’s almost as if she is simultaneously crucifying and praising her lover for whatever expectation they created: perhaps it was well-intended, but it certainly poisoned the relationship.
________________________________________________________________________
5.
“I overthink your punctuation use.”
— LORDE, “THE LOUVRE”
In the age of texting, when most of our conversing happens through a screen rather than face-to-face, we have very little to go on to determine how a person intends their words to come across. So, when texting has all but destroyed proper punctuation and grammar, it’s refreshing to hear Lorde openly admit she spends way too much time overanalyzing her lover’s punctuation. Is it excessive? Maybe. Is it a sign she actually is the “sweetheart psychopathic crush” she claims to be in later lines? Probably. Is it proof that all has not been lost? Absolutely.
________________________________________________________________________
6.
“Don’t bite the hand that feeds or you’ll, you’ll never eat, no.”
— KATY PERRY, “POWER”
Katy Perry doesn’t always get empowerment anthems right. “Firework” was decent but overplayed; “Roar” was obnoxious and overwrought; and “Rise” was too tepid and misplaced. But with “Power,” Perry and her songwriters finally achieve something close to perfection. It recognizes culpability in the demise of a relationship while also asserting individuality. It asserts revitalization while also offering a strong warning to future lovers: despite the cliché, Perry makes them keenly aware that they will not survive if they take her for granted.
________________________________________________________________________
7.
“How could anybody have you and lose you and not lose their mind, too?”
— ST. VINCENT, “LOS AGELESS”
For however trite the initial inspiration for “Los Ageless” may be—Los Angeles’ obsession with youth and conflating it with beauty—the mania St. Vincent instills in it is inspired. Instrumentally, St. Vincent uses her guitar to highlight the dangerous spiral this obsession with youth can create. And by the time she gets to the chorus, her words and ideas have gotten sucked up in that same manic tornado of emotions. When she delivers the final line of the chorus, then, it seems she has already begun losing her mind trying to iron out the logic of having and losing and how (in)sanity plays into it all.
________________________________________________________________________
8.
“I do my makeup in somebody else’s car.”
— LORDE, “GREEN LIGHT”
There is something incredibly poetic about how Lorde narrates something as mundane as hurriedly applying makeup on the way to a party. It’s equal parts poetic and acerbic: her ex-lover no longer gets to witness what it takes for her to become the person she shares with the world. He no longer gets to reap the rewards that come from wooing such a made-up beauty. She’s not his, the car’s not his, and whoever this “somebody” is is none of his business—a reality she makes abundantly clear throughout the rest of the track.
________________________________________________________________________
9.
“If I’m not evolving / I’m just another robot / Taking up oxygen.”
— KATY PERRY, “BIGGER THAN ME”
While Perry’s promise for “purposeful pop” may have gotten a big muddled over the course of the Witness album campaign, it’s strongest and clearest on “Bigger Than Me,” a track focused on the political fallout of Clinton’s loss for presidency and what a single person’s impact can be on the world. Perry doesn’t offer any specific advice for how to move forward, other than the notion that we must evolve past the upsets. Progress cannot be made if we stay the same, stand still, or simply resign ourselves to being “just one grain” in the sand.
________________________________________________________________________
10.
“I live off the echoes of your ‘I love you’s’ / But I still feel the blows from all of your ‘don’t want to’s.’”
— KATY PERRY, “DÉJÀ VU”
Post-breakup, it may often be difficult to reconcile lingering feelings of love with whatever feelings of resentment and rejection may be threatening to boil over. In “Déjà Vu,” Perry explores this emotional paradox and others, only to realize there isn’t an easy solution for preventing the cycle from continuing because the heartbreaking truth is that the memories of love lost is not just painful but also strangely sustaining. We need the echoes to remind us of what can be, even if it can’t be right now or with the person we thought it would be.